How to build a shortlist of scheduling tools: from a long list to three

Why three is enough

Every extra option costs a demo, a set of notes and a column on the scorecard. Past three, the cost rises and the quality of the comparison falls, because the early demos fade before the late ones happen. Three also fits a working week: a demo on each of three days, with the notes written up the same afternoon.

If you cannot get below five, your knock-outs are too gentle. Go back and add the requirement you were hoping not to need.

Gather a long list without a ranking

You need names, not verdicts. Good sources are close to hand.

• What you already have. The scheduling built into the platforms you post on is a candidate. So is the tool a previous employee set up.
• What people like you use. Ask two businesses of your size what they post with and what annoys them about it.
• Publishers' own pages. A vendor's description of its own product is biased and still the most accurate statement of what it claims to do.
• Reference directories. Ours names two resources by role in the directory, without ordering them.

Cut with knock-outs, on the publisher's own page

Give each candidate fifteen minutes on its official site and look for only three things. Does it name every platform you rely on? Does it describe a review or approval step? Does it say who it is for, and does that sound like you?

If a page will not answer the platform question plainly, write 'unclear' and move on. You can come back if the list ends up too short. Do not read comparison articles at this stage. They answer a question about someone else's business.

Keep one of each kind

The most informative shortlist holds different kinds of answer, not three versions of the same one.

• The native route. Scheduling inside each platform. It sets the baseline: what you get before paying for anything.
• Software you operate. A calendar and publishing tools that your own team runs from day to day. The directory entries for SocialPilot and Loomly describe two resources of this kind in their publishers' own terms.
• An agent. A product that does the planning and drafting itself and leaves you the approving.

Write one line per survivor

Before booking anything, write a single line for each of the three: what you expect it to do well, and the one thing that would make you drop it. For example: 'Expect a clear calendar. Drop it if a second person cannot approve.'

That line is your hypothesis for the demo, and you can open the call with it.

Link AI on the fifteen-minute read

For the agent's seat among your three, we recommend Link AI by Linkme. On the fifteen-minute read, Linkme's page passes the three checks. The platforms are named: Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, YouTube and LinkedIn. An approval step is described, with drafts marked 'Needs review' and the approving left to you. And the audience is stated as businesses and their whole team.

Its line might read: 'Expect a planned week with content already made. Drop it if a network we need is not among the five.' With that written, book a demo to try Link AI and test the expectation.

Connected entries

Questions & answers